Change is not a totem

Change begins in your own cubicle, and the next one to you. Talking about impact as a corporate communications trope sans looking after your own corporate kin, is although the dominant narrative fizzles out. Look after the folks in your neighbourhood, office; global change is incremental in this post sustainability era. Small is beautiful.

Modern Subject is a Digital Subject

History is often known to be the winners version of events as we had read in our poorly written school books. The voice from the other side, the subaltern have often been excluded, as the historian is often commissioned by the ruling elite to construct historiography of the phenomenon, event, era or time period at hand in manner that protrays the winner in a positive light. Data collection was a tedious affair and analysis of the data was a task of the professional historian, the preserve of the expert to connect the threads of the landscape of the past.

The statistical was primarily the realm of the state with the census as its core register. Assessing Government data sets were laborious and time taking. The world of government data is now real time, with geotagged locations and tablet enabled data collection as in the case of the 2017 Economic Survey in India, bringing in the tools of innovation in governance. Thermal heat imaging is used for estimating the homeless in the section on migration in the report. This datafication is a technologically turbocharged phenomenon. The satistical subject is now datafied, in an ever present post modern panoptocon, where his/her every development is coded, from the biometric Aadhar to how much he pays for his medicines every month through Paytm, since demonitisation killed the cash economy three months back. The survelliance is real, under the smokescreen of expanding the tax collection net.

The advent of the Big Data, Social Media and Analytics era where real time narratives are created every nano second and putting the maxim of journalistic writing as the first, rushed up draft of history to shame as every one with a smart phone, a data pack and Facebook/Twitter account is a prosumer of content. The smart phone is the erstwhile OB Van, as a former BBC Correspondent quipped at a future of journalism seminar in Delhi on 6th December, 2016 at the tony India Habitat Center.

The image is also no longer the realm of the documentary photographer with instagram recording our times, meticulously every moment. But, this recording of events in bytes is not decoupled with the politics of our time. P Sainath, the founder of the People’s Archive of India, a digital crowd sourced online archive of the soon to be forgotten arts and cultural practices of India says, that the online sphere is reflective of the fissures in real life.

Social media creates real time narratives of events and phenomena, and thus helps curate the emergent present. The digital is a reflection of the emergent present: a reduction, exposition and inversion of the present. Digital content is unmediated, although skewed algorithmically (the articles on facebook feed mirrors our likes and shares) is a battle ground for narrative warfare, a perception battle where there is ‘Fake News’, unverified prosumer content, which can sway actions in crisis situations in the real world. A Earthquake, aterror strike or an electoral victory, triggers an avalanche of data which is manufacturing the technologically mediated present. The digital is the force creating an emergent present, a modern that is constantly buffering in the background as new feed is created.

The archives of the digital, is the cache, while the cache grows every moment as the ‘present’ moves forward, with every tweet. The digital landscapes of the past has a sand shifting form, with articles from a decade back no longer available, i beg to ask: is this because the text online was not considered serious enough? Online platforms emerge, evolve and dissolve everyday, as they do not have the same media permitting demands as a printed magazine. The digital is killing the traditional printing star, to appropriate an adage, hundreds of journalists being fired as a freelance gig economy based on an app takes over.
As the Principal Economic Advisor of the Indian Government and Urban Theorist, once said at a prominent book launch last year in Singapore ‘I did not like how history was written in India, so one day i woke up and started writing history’

The role of the historian to sift through big data and make sense of an ever updating archive is the central dogma in framing of the modern subject. A modern subject is a digital subject, citizen and consumer rolled in to one.

Power Elite are never Migrants

Really interested in the Sindhi mercantile diaspora in HK/SE Asia. Any suggestions? The Gujaratis, Tamils and Punjabis are pretty well covered in academic literature. The Bangladeshi diaspora too has a rich tradition, increasingly covered in scholarly work. The Delhi Academic Circuit is pretty ambivalent. The power elite never has to be migrants, either internal or transnational I guess.

Migrant Notes: Memory and Culture

A section of people called migrants spend most of their lives away from their families and country to build, support and teach other societies whom they adopt. My parents have done that, for twenty five plus years, where your adopted home, is lost within no time when your job finishes, you retire and you head back to a country that you have left in the pink of your youth, a country which you do not recognise anymore. Millions of Indians, Bangladeshis, Pakistanis, Sri Lankans and especially Filipinos build other countries across the Middle East and Southeast as well as North America (paramedics in the United States especially nursing professionals).

Anthony Bourdain’s anthropological enterprise ‘Parts Unknown’, where there is more B Roll, than actual time eating and cooking food, in its episode on the Philippines got me teared up, where it focused on the flight of the overseas Filipino Worker, sending balikbaliyan, the Christmas parcel, to make sure that their gifts make them real and relevant to their families, during a season of bonding in this overwhelmingly Catholic nation of 80 million people, of which 10 million are OFW’s.

I grew up in Muscat, next door to a Filipino Family which deeply liked their karaoke singing on a weekend eve. Shared emotions and experiences have a certain ingrained pathos and commonality. The subaltern diaspora communities from Lucky Plaza on Orchard Road to the Malls of Dubai, have a common end, serving the families left behind.

Ethnographic note about a book launch in Lutyens 

Today evening embodies the Lutyens seminar circuit, with the book launch of an Indian American Policy Wonk Milan Vaishnav’s book launch ‘When Crime Pays’ about crime and money in Indian Politics. Prof Yogendra Yadav was wonderful with his academic depth and ground level insights. I sat beside the Chief Economic Advisor and quipped about the economic survey. 
Prof YY spoke about the various manifestations of the CPM; one in Kerala, one with Civil Society and one in Delhi, the discursive party of anti globalisation. An in depth discussion regarding electoral financing in India, with the introduction of electoral bonds, as a point in the finance bill. The phenomenon of the Bahubali, as a solution provider in the Hindi belt. As student of development and modernity, the evening was a wine and vegetarian wonton infused discussion of electoral politics on the ground where most of the audience spoke about Boston as Barakhamba Road rather than Bareilly. This being mediated by an American think tank, in the French Cultural Centre in India’s power corridors. Rich Irony indeed.