Recently i had been to a by invitation only event of the IndiCorps Fellowship, a group of young Diaspora Indians working in deprived communities by connecting with them by living in the community and trying to help the community by addressing a central question, whether it is gender equality or sanitation or micro-entrepreneurship in Hyderbad or Girls Education next door to the India Pak Border, these are a bunch of inspiring folks. One of them Neal Somchand who spoke about Palliative care raised this game changing question- What is the North Star in your life? 

This question really spoke to me within. The right questions lead us to the correct answers. What is that we wish to achieve in our lives- power, money, fame or bringing a smile on the less fortunate. 

We cannot have everything. Its either my way or the highway.

I have been an avid news industry watcher since i am six or seven years old and i a’nt kiddin folks.  My childhood idols were Barkha Dutt and Rajdeep Sardesai, and i had a crush on Mishal Hussein ; the newscaster on BBC World. I breathe and live news. Over some time now, the fine line between reality tv and genuine news is blurred in the mad rush over trps and in turn ad placements. Sometimes it is very difficult to believe any story on the media. NDTV seems to having a clear Congress orientation while Zee like the Express group has a rightest BJP esque inclination.  The Guhawati incident has left me shell shocked in the understanding to what extent channels can stoop for trp’s like the regional tv reporter did.

It is so important for the viewer to analyse the news for oneself. Be disenchanted and critical.  Arnab of Times Now follows a Fox News type editorial policy, which neither ‘Clear’ nor ‘Balanced’ as the Fox News USA motto goes. Arnab is a Sociologist influenced by the Foucault school, which is post structuralist. He seems to shout down participants instead of engaging them in a discussion.

Alternative media platforms are emerging which are too niche for my liking. I admire Caravan, Open Magazine and Tehelka but they are too elitist in my opinion.  Al Jazeera is cool, but how many Indians watch it?

Its about time that we have our own Al Jazeera

 

There is an interesting line which i read in Aseem Srivastava and Ashish Kothari’s timely book on Development, Environment and Globalization issues called as ” Churning the Earth: The Making of a Global India. The line was implying that the huge surge in Microfinance is not because all the poor want to start shops and small ventures but because multilateral financial institutions having a share in the pie. Social Ventures either run on CSR grant funds or on philanthropic donations. Very few social ventures actually break even on selling some service or product. Either way these are all ultimately tied in to the commodity value chain in the neo liberal system.

With the advent of Globalization and Information Communication Technologies, Social Entrepreneurship has been catapulted to the world stage. Social Innovation uses the tools of the market economy with altruistic developmental sector aims and aspires to meet social needs. The same set of folks who criticize the market economy for its ills, do not hesitate to take in their funds to fun their social ventures. The power lies in the hands of the folks who pays for the bills.  So, it is the capitalist who dictates the terms in the socialist sector. 

I am happy if a few livelihoods are improved even it is a unholy match as Chairman Mao once said: A Cat whether Black or White is effective as long as it catches mice. It is the impact that matters. Lets cut the hippocracy and concentrate on the impact. 

Non Profits serve a critical role in lubricating the society’s larger scheme of  vital services which sometimes the government falls short of delivering. They are the part most loathed and least respected for everyone expects people in the Non Profit Sector to do charity. I remember an Old Communist Joke in Russia in this regard; that a supervisor asks the worker, ‘why is’nt he working?’ The worker replies to the supervisor ‘You pretend to pay our salaries, in the same light i pretend to work’ !.  As in the case for all workers, money matters as everyone has got bills to pay at the end of the month. The question which I have raised in the heading of this article is a textbook question for folks following the not for profit space, should we target scale for cost effectiveness and economies of scale or should one stay niche and concentrate on metrics of quality, in other words should a NPO/Social Enterprise stay a boutique investment fund or go public and venture into retail services to borrow a financial services analogy.

I would suggest that the Business Model for Non Profits should be tailored to meet its end goal. It has to driven by its impact and the number of lives it can change. Of course values and altruistic motivations are the catalyst for the founding team of the Non Profit, but the mundane biting realities of daily operations lead people to think about ‘commercial’ jargons such as quantifying impact of the donor dollar and fundraising dilute the soul of the activist within the social entrepreneur. It does not really matter if the non-profit is dependent on grant money or its selling some variety of services to break even. If it serves the need of the community which it serves, then it has done a decent job.

 

In the hallowed annals of Business Academia, there is a lot of hue and cry about the nature of the Business Model, but a true entrepreneur considers his venture a work in progress and ideas or models in business literature do not hold much weight as the end should justify which ever means he uses.  Whether it is a Gawad Kalinga or a Grameen or a Community Enterprise in our area, it is the impact which matters ultimately. Scale is Sexy for the media to cover, but we have SKS fiasco to ponder upon whenever we think of Scale. Scale at what cost is also an important question to ponder when thinking through such questions.

 

I would like to wind up this read by suggesting some limitations of scale. I am not against scale if it is required as in scale works wonders in healthcare and financial inclusion. Just think Aravind Eye and Grameen and scale seems to do the magic. But some things are far more effective when dealing with groups at risk, an Old Age Home or a Half Way Home is best operated when a bottom line driven mandate is missing from the equation. But when a business enterprise such as a restaurant chain in Singapore founded by an ex offender employs other ex-offenders, it serves a social end by creating employment opportunities for ex offenders which are usually rare in an Asian context with the bottom-line being taken care of.  The theme of this article is a classic chicken and egg question, and the debate will continue which one will takes on more emphasis, as with all things in life- context matters.

 

I have been very happy to note that Bollywood films are going realistic in terms of their ending especially in love stories.  Ek Main aur Ek Tu had a serious real ending, the women is older by a year and becomes friends with the guy who falls in love with him; And more importantly the lady stays good friends with the guy who loves her. She likes him because the guy because he is ‘perfectly average’ and not because he is a super stud, a person will a normal guy wont be able to be.

Superheros are good to watch on screen, might not be all that good in real life actually! We go to the movies for escapist Bollywood fare but is refreshing to find the ‘real’ getting space in a manufactured ‘dream’.  Teri Meri Kahani another very contemporary film is just the opposite; the old boy meet girl story with inter-temporal treatment over three geographies. The end storyline is that the boy gets to marry the girl and they live happily ever after. It is a feel good factor when we leave the theater after spending 400 bucks on tickets and popcorn but it is different connect the director makes when we get a taste of reality in an artistic, aesthetic manner.

Cocktail has dealt with relationships in a very progressive manner. A love triangle in which the  super hot party animal Veronica dates the super stud playboy Gautam and Veronica’s Friend Meera from India, whom she is helping out is the third locus in the love triangle. Veronica is madly in love with Gautam and Gautam is in love with the plain jane Meera and Meera eventually succumbs to the charms of Gautam, yes as the film tagline goes – Love is complicated and Relationships are confusing, so are in real life. The best part of the film is the mature handling of the narrative. In one scene where Meera, Veronica and Gautam are sitting across a kitchen table and Gautam says to Veronica: You love me, I love her (pointing to Meera) and the tense situation is diffused in a cordial manner.

The times when audiences will buy sweet endings is passe. Real is the new cool. Bollywood is understanding the pulse of the urbane multiplex going viewer finally.

Islam, unfortunately is one of the most misunderstood religio-cultural frameworks in the world particularly post 9/11 although the it has drifted away from the public eye, the Faith is still grossly misunderstood. As a non Moslem who has been raised in Oman i have been surrounded by Muslim friends through  out my life. I have been fortunate to have resided in three culturally distinct parts of the Muslim World: South Asia, Gulf and South East Asia. What strikes me is that the common foundations of the Faith are shared universally but are practiced very differently in their regions. In the run up to Ramadan or Ramzan in South Asia i would like to contrast how Iftar or the meal at the breaking of the fast is practiced. The meal in the Bahasa speaking world  would be rice based as i have been to an iftar in Singapore and i have been to many an Iftar in Oman- the meals are very different.

A Bohra Muslim Iftar is grounded in a Western Indian Ethos rather than a Middle Eastern one. Magreb Islam is very different from a Mashreq version in its cultural undercurrents. The attempt at monoculturalization of Muslims in the media is gross incorrect.  A Bengali Iftar is Bengali and a Punjabi Iftar is very Lahori! 

The attitude towards music is another aspect where various sub cultures differ. The ‘White’ Arabs of the Levant and the Berbers of the Maghreb has very rich musical traditions such as the Rai tradition. Remember Cheb Mami and Khaled?

Sufism holds music as a central part of meditation. Someone who holds a puritanical view might object but that is plural character of Islam which is not known in the wider world. Indonesian and Malaysian Muslims have been amazing ambassadors of Plural Islam; modern yet moderate.

Not to leave the Turks and Central Asian Muslims, the Muslim World is very diverse as much as the Buddhist, Hindu or Secular Christian nations of the West. The unraveling of the thesis begins….

In this age of post idea, consumerist societies that we reside in and i do not wish to sound like i am writing a term paper for a social theory grad course but as an avid social media enthusiast who has been an active participant on social media platforms since 2008, i can accept the emotional cost of creating a self which is not totally you; you wish to be that in your real life but simply cannot hence we try to create an illusionary identity which is not truly us. Hence this identity is discontinuous with our real self in the flesh and blood world. This is troublesome and inconsistent; gives rise to schizophrenic situations. I have this insatiable hunger like any other word artist to be liked. Evolution is good, transformation is necessary but this constant ‘approval addiction’ kills ones own self worth. The likes on facebook and the shares give this need an acknowledgement and a filler up. A Re-tweet from a prominent person who follows you can give you an ego boost.  It is ego play at the end of the day.

The perennial micro-managing of social media profiles has a really damaging effect on self perception. If a certain person does not respond to a message or a tweet, it dents your morale for a flicker of a second. A Cyber Sanyaas or a Digital Fast is so necessary. There is a life beyond virtual existence. There is also a life beyond people approving you.  We need to connect with ‘The Man Inside my Head’ to appropriate Pico Iyer’s latest literary endevour  in this situation.

Which Identity are we comfortable beneath our skin? Think about it.