Had an interesting dialogue with a group of think tank young Turks with social science or public policy background looking forward to work in the ESG space , some inputs could be handy for young professionals across the board, as the green jobs ecosystem could be divided into :

• Rating agency analyst jobs – solid back end research jobs with easy transferable skills, abundant mass market entry level opportunities
• sustainability and energy market research analyst jobs – plenty of jobs at the entry level
• MEL and development consultancy jobs
• boutique ESG consulting firms such as Envint and EMC in Mumbai which offer plenty of quality openings for entry level
• INGOs resource persons
• big 4 analyst jobs (very competitive)
• ESIA consultant work (solid technical work but not the best paid)
• MBB consultancy specialist track jobs (hardest to crack as blue chip credentials are needed)
• in-house sustainability teams in big corporations
• ESG risk and disclosure work in banks and MFIs

The rule of thumb is that the start ups offer steep learning and larger firms offer better specialist understanding plus better pay, make your choice dependent on your situation. Each of these specialties need it’s own vocational grammar. Good certifications which young professionals can tap :

• CFA in ESG Investing
• GRI Certified Sustainability Professional

As any one in the just transition business knows, workforce competency is a material issue.

Anti Green Washing Auditing, Assurance and Disclosure are growth areas.

A selection of visual notes from KL.

A proactive sustainability report or ESG disclosure is a window into the culture of an organization and is often a heuristic for robust systems and processes. It is legal compliance yet superior quality disclosures will attract the right kind of investor. Culture is everything as it shows that the correct processes are followed.

Transparency is the subliminal message for trust, and in the hyper digital climate era, reporting data is trust. It is like a non-profit with audited financial statements and annual reports for three years before a legacy foundation can come and fund a program. For an investor in the venture space, ESG data is a proxy for systems in place. It is your alignment to market access and investor trust.

An enormous limitation of ESG disclosures is the partitioning of the metrics into silos, where the interdependence of the numbers is not factored in, how do two metrics intertwine in a particular context to produce risk in a real time manner which is useful to the decision maker? The sociopolitical context can attenuate or amplify the risk, which is missing from the ESG discourse as standardization for comparability is the impulse rather than how is the data valuable for investor decision making at this moment.

AI Models are great, but real risk is experienced on the ground where the incident happens, prior to ossifying into an incident statistic tucked into the reams of the disclosure deluge.

ESG is the new compliance, as ESIAs were and still are, as it is an audit and disclosure play for a wider audience than environmental permitting, as the primary driver is benchmarking for an investor target group. Fifteen years back environmental compliance was the cost of doing business, as in this climate scenario ESG is the cost of doing business. It is about communicating impact for your stakeholders, and not really about impact itself. Many conflate doing ESG reporting as impact, but impact is an input, reporting is an output of the process to create impact. The lowest hanging fruit in sustainability or ESG is to hire a sustainability manager, yet it is a compliance officer in the GRC function.

Doing ESG is hygiene, like filing taxes- one does not call the company secretary as impact. No wonder green washing risk is the leading risk for enterprises in 2024.

Thirteen years of changethinker.com !

I started writing my blog as a platform which is free of the usual constraints of the political economy of knowledge production. I write with a ‘global from below’ lens and have brought the subaltern voices of the global city such as the cabbie, food worker and the barber to a legitimate register of globalisation.

I will keep writing, making image art and scribbling spoken word as our voices matter.

Jumma Biryani.

Nasi Biryani in the Nusantara is a creole dish with the model of Mandi Rice and the meat cooked separately. The egg in the biryani is a constant from south Asian variants, yet the familiar feel and a distinct character go hand in hand.

The Nasi Biryani is an index of convergence from KL to Kolkata to Dindigul to Masqat to Kuwait City.

It’s the time for the year in review which has been a year of learning and transition. From Johannesburg to Jakarta, it’s been the year of the global south travel, and having spent a third of the year in SE Asia, and reading a program in SE Asian Studies- it’s been a blessing. Having read Abdoumaliq Simone’s work, it was good to be in both his cities of intellectual interest.

It’s also a year of health reminders, with a dear parent undergoing a surgery recently, and I got operated on my eye in July that was pending for many years.

I had the opportunity this year to train, write and speak on ESG matters, and blog each day. In all sincerity, just feel blessed to survive the year. It’s time to rebuild again with a gentle smile.

Wishing all a good holiday season.

The current edition of The Entrepreneur’s from The Monocle stable, is on entrepreneurship in the Emirates, which is really the start up hub of the Middle East, South Asia and Africa. May be the history of the Trucial States has to do with it, as Dubai became a Free Port in 1905, prompting the first wave of migration of Persian Merchants from the rule of the Shah who had raised taxes for merchants from southern Persia, to increase revenue.

A lot of the trade in gold in South Asia was mediated through Dubai until the 1990’s. Culture is downstream of History and is vital for turbocharged entrepreneurship.

A good reference is Prof Todd Reisz ‘s Showpeice City and Temporary City by Prof Yasser Elsheshtawy

I was missing Masqat and the fare at the Arab World and the Mandi places in Al Khuwair, Ghala and Azaiba, so what does as ‘Desi Khaleeji’ do in such circumstances? Head to Wadi Hadramout, for Adeni Tea and Mandi Rice in Jalan Ampang. The place feels somewhere out of Dakhliyah, with a space-time compression identical out of Oman.

KL has a large Arab student diaspora and refugee communities, and I often speak Arabic here with Malaysians and Indonesians, and is a lingua franca of the Nusantara. The jawi script is Arabic and Indian Ocean circulations dominate.

The sensory scapes of the place, is deeply familiar and satisfying.

On the business end, this edition of The Entrepreneur’s from the Monocle stable is on entrepreneurship in the Emirates, which is the embodiment of the free port ethos of Dubai since 1905, which prompted the migration of Persian merchants, traces of which can be found in current day Al Fahidi in Bur Dubai.